Exports of elegant Swiss watches to China have plunged. Sales of Mercedes-Benz and other premium sedans are slowing. And high-end restaurants, coming off their worst Chinese New Year festival in years, are starting to change their menus to lure ordinary families.
At a “Montblanc” shop in downtown Beijing, sales clerks recall the days when they rang up as many as 10 of the top-selling fountain pens every day. And never mind the $1,400 price tag: The platinum-plated pen capped with a half-carat diamond was a particular favourite. Nowadays the store sells one such pen every two to three days, said a saleswoman surnamed Ren, adding sadly that her pay is commission-based. Such is the state of living large in the world’s second-largest luxury market.
The cause of the downturn is not economic – it is political
In the last few months, China’s new leader, President Xi Jinping, has been pressing a campaign to rein in the lavish ways of the nation’s political and military elite. Warning that corruption could threaten the Communist Party’s survival, Xi has waged a highly public effort to rid officialdom of ostentatious living.
Ceremonial red carpets and floral decor are out. Flying coach is in. Party cadres are being told to double up in hotel rooms.
And in what has become a particular crowd pleaser with the public, Beijing is going after those who have long abused the privileges of military license plates, which almost guarantee immunity from traffic laws and other such inconveniences.
It’s a much-debated question here whether this wide-ranging campaign is aimed at the root causes of corruption and income inequality, or only addressing the most visible symptoms. Whichever the case, Xi and his lieutenants have good reason for their frugality program.
Beijing has long maintained control in part by tacitly promising that over time everyone will benefit from the country’s new wealth. Rampant corruption and the garish displays of affluence by senior officials and their families strike at the heart of Beijing’s promise that it is working to make life better for all. Ordinary Chinese, often through microblogs and other social media, have increasingly lashed out at what they see as a privileged class of political elites.
Minxin Pei, an expert on Chinese governance at Claremont McKenna College, thinks Xi has two objectives with his anticorruption program: “To appease the Chinese public to show that he has heard their voice … [and] to tell officials throughout the system that the new leadership has absolute authority.”
Whatever the government’s purpose, the campaign has affected spending on all kinds of high-end goods and services. Some analysts blame Xi’s crackdown for China’s disappointing economic growth in the first quarter, which has brought financial pain to many workers.
The repercussions of the austerity drive aren’t just domestic. Official visits sponsored by government entities to the United States and other countries are rapidly declining, according to travel industry sources. That is sure to be felt by California, a popular destination among the Chinese.
Most purveyors of luxury goods in China are sitting tight for now, betting that the freeze will end soon.
“I still believe that gift-giving, as long as it is not conspicuous, will remain an important behaviour in China,” said Pierre Coppere, chairman of distiller Pernod Ricard Asia, reassuring analysts recently after a double-digit drop in revenue from sales of Scotch whiskey during the Chinese New Year period.
Gift-giving is a way of life for many Chinese businesses and bureaucrats, as are bribes
Over the years, Communist Party officials have found plenty of ways to pocket gains from land sales, hiring and operation of businesses on the side.
In many cases, the extravagant spending comes from official entertainment funds. Even though the party’s manuals spell out standards for purchases in detailed fashion – specifying, for example, the largest engine size that each level of government can buy for its fleet – the regulations have seldom been enforced.
Civil servants earn modest incomes – no more than $850 a month for a mid-level central government official, some state media reports say – but many have spruced up their lifestyles by travelling first class, dining at premium restaurants and holding lavish ceremonies, all on the taxpayers’ dime. Officials charged an estimated $57 billion worth of expenses on about 10 million government-issued credit cards last year, according to Emerging Asia Group, a research firm in Shanghai.
Xi has made examples of officials who have been publicly criticised, fired or prosecuted, mostly at low levels of government, for using taxpayer money on banquets and trips, for example, or keeping a public vehicle for personal use.Source: Restraint is the new red in China (Los Angeles Times)
- Rich Chinese shift focus from growing to preserving assets (Chinadailymail.com)
- Being a Chinese official: Not all it’s cracked up to be (Chinadailymail.com)
- China facing widening inequities and corruption (Chinadailymail.com)
- You: Restraint is the new red in China (latimes.com)
- Restraint is the new red in China (latimes.com)
- Restraint is the new red in China (omaha.com)
- Dream of the Red Future: will the Chinese Dream become an enduring classic? (line21project.wordpress.com)
- Xi Jinping meets North Korean envoy (wantchinatimes.com)
- Xi Jinping set for ‘laid-back’ US visit: ambassador (wantchinatimes.com)